CMW COP31 reaction: Climate focus of Article 6 survives fossil-fueled market lobby – for now

COP31 saw a push to drum up interest in Article 6 carbon markets at any cost – but you can’t bargain with climate action. CMW warns an upcoming 2028 review of the UN carbon market rulebook risks prioritising financial profit over real emissions reductions.

After two days of delay, COP31 came to a close amidst deep divides between governments. The outcome illustrates major tensions on climate finance and the pervasive influence of fossil fuel interests, also visible in the Article 6 carbon market negotiations, where vested lobbying pushed to advance carbon markets at any cost.

Ahead of and during COP31, numerous voices driven by financial interests encouraged countries to weaken existing Article 6 carbon market rules at the expense of fair and effective climate action. Luckily, the rulebook remains intact, yet with a major review of Article 6 scheduled for 2028, COP31 showed a growing lobbying effort to push profit over effectiveness. This year’s lobbying efforts intensified from what we observed in Belém at COP30.

Efforts to weaken the rules are expected to intensify at COP32, and governments must resist calls from the carbon market industry to push climate action to the throes of an unregulated market, a demand also echoed by the scientific community.

Quotes

Carbon Market Watch policy director Sam Van den plas said, “COP31 has shown that the carbon market industry is still pulling in the wrong direction. They must refocus on credible and truly high integrity projects instead of stoking up governments to undermine Article 6 from within. It’s long past time for them to leave the vested fossil fuel interests behind and focus on more effective and fairer carbon markets.”

Isa Mulder, policy expert on global carbon markets, said, “Governments missed a chance at COP31 to learn from the glaring mistakes shown up in early carbon trades under Article 6.2. Clearly, some countries have an interest in keeping this framework a ‘Wild West’ for carbon trading. They can stick their head in the sand, but the atmosphere will see the result when the emissions reductions that countries account for on paper never materialise in the real world, while local communities bear the brunt of the absence of proper human rights protections.”

Federica Dossi, policy expert on global carbon markets said, “The Paris Agreement carbon crediting mechanism (PACM) is at a crossroads. Either it sets a new and more responsible benchmark for global carbon markets, or it is steered by financial and other vested interests, becoming just another cheap get-out-of-jail-free card for polluters. Governments need to step up and stop trying to import into Article 6.4 the flawed business models of failed mechanisms like the CDM or the low standards typical of the voluntary carbon market.”

Author

  • Gavin Mair

    Gavin is a member of the communications team. He formerly supported the work of MSPs in the Scottish Parliament, and held responsibility for media output and office management for two MEPs prior to Brexit. He is an experienced campaigner, relishing the challenge of communicating for causes that have a social and environmental impact and is motivated by CMW’s mission of holding businesses and governments to account as they move towards essential environmental ambitions and transitions. When not fighting the good fight Gavin can typically be found enjoying live music or attending to his houseplants.

    View all posts

Related posts

Scroll to top

Join our mailing list

Stay in touch and receive our monthly newsletter, campaign updates, event invites and more.