European Commission finds a lack of details, concrete measures in draft national energy and climate plans

BRUSSELS 18 June 2019. Today, the European Commission published its analysis and country-specific recommendations for the EU Member States on their draft National Energy and Climate Plans (NECPs). Largely confirming findings by LIFE PlanUp, the Commission urges governments to strengthen their plans in order to bridge the gap between the EU climate targets and what the Member States are putting forward.

The “ambition gap” concerns the deployment of renewable energy sources and energy efficiency measures in particular. Consequently, the recommendations call on several Member States to reconsider their level of ambition to ensure that this gap is closed by the time they submit their final national energy and climate plans (NECPs) in December.

Looking specifically at the buildings, agricultural and transport sectors, PlanUp recently analysed the draft energy and climate plans of five EU countries – Poland, Romania, Hungary, Italy and Spain. The analyses found a lack of concrete climate measures in the transport, agricultural and buildings sectors as well as insufficient public participation processes.

Commenting on the Commission recommendations on behalf of PlanUp, Agnese Ruggiero, Policy Officer at Carbon Market Watch said:

These recommendations confirm our findings that showed a clear ambition gap and a lack of concrete action by national governments. The recent EU elections made it clear that Europeans want their governments to take decisive action to deal with the climate crisis. National climate plans are a unique opportunity to do so while attracting clean investments that will create jobs.

Transport, buildings and agriculture – key sectors to achieve deep emission cuts

Transport is responsible for around a quarter of greenhouse gas emissions in the EU and the largest sector under the Effort Sharing Regulation (ESR). The Commission urges governments to put this sector at the centre of their energy and climate plans and to include more concrete and detailed measures.

The European buildings sector is responsible for 40% of energy consumption and around 15% of greenhouse gas emissions. It needs to play a key role in helping the EU achieve its energy efficiency and renewable energy targets.

As the Commission rightly points out, more effort is required to achieve energy efficiency improvements in buildings. This would not only cut emissions but would also reduce energy bills for households, and increase employment in the buildings sector.

The agricultural sector receives relatively little attention in the Commission recommendations, although it is a major source of greenhouse gas emissions and has vast potential for emission reductions.

More substantive policies and quantified expected results will make it easier for the Member States to achieve their climate goals and track their progress in all these sectors.

Agnese Ruggiero:

Lack of details and concrete measures is a cross-cutting issue when it comes to the transport, buildings and agricultural sectors in the draft plans. Effective measures in these sectors will also bring tangible co-benefits such as clean air and better health.

Strong policies will require strong public support

While only touching the topic briefly in the recommendations, the Commission urges governments to effectively involve stakeholders, including local and regional authorities and civil society organisations in the development of the final plans.

Agnese Ruggiero concluded:

While we welcome the recommendation to involve stakeholders in the development of the final plans, the Commission doesn’t give public participation the attention it deserves. Transparency and inclusive dialogue are fundamental in order to ensure public support for climate policies.

The EU Member States have until the end of the year to submit their final energy and climate plans for the 2021-2030 period.

ENDS

Contacts:
Agnese Ruggiero – Policy Officer
[email protected]
Tel: +32 497 81 86 24

Kaisa Amaral – Communications Director
[email protected]
Tel: +32 485 07 68 90

Notes to editors:

Key figures in the Commission communication include:

  • Renewable energy gap: under current draft plans, the share of renewable energy would reach between 30.4% and 31.9% in 2030, instead of 32%.
  • Energy efficiency gap: the aggregate assessment shows a substantial gap with the EU 2030 target levels of primary and final energy consumption. For primary energy consumption, the gap ranges from 118 to 43 Mtoe, which corresponds to attaining 26.3% to 30.2%, while for the final energy consumption the gap ranges from 85 to 26 Mtoe, which corresponds to attaining 26.5% to 30.7%.
  • Greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reduction in the sectors covered by the Effort Sharing Regulation: with the measures included in the draft NECPs the EU can achieve a 28% GHG emission reduction by 2030 but will fail to achieve the mandatory 30%.
Useful links:

European Commission assessment of the 28 draft NECPs and country-specific recommendations

LIFE Plan assessments of five draft energy and climate plans: ItalySpainPolandHungaryRomania
LIFE PlanUp website
PressKit PlanUp
Main findings in good practice governance
Guide on EU Climate & Sectoral Decarbonisation Policies

About LIFE PlanUp:

LIFE PlanUp supports the shift to a low-carbon and resilient economy through the development and implementation of effective and ambitious national 2030 energy and climate plans (NECPs) in Hungary, Poland, Romania, Spain and Italy. A key objective of the PlanUp project is to strengthen the climate and energy governance processes in these countries by increasing the involvement of local and regional authorities (LRAs) and civil society organisations (CSOs) in the development and implementation of the NECPs.

Project partners: Carbon Market Watch, Energy Cities, Transport & Environment, Climact, European Environmental Bureau.

National Affiliates: Polish Green Network (Poland), ISD Fundatia (Poland), Clean Air Action Group (Hungary), ADEPT (Romania), GEC Bucovina (Romania), Legambiente (Italy), Ecodes (Spain).

More information on LIFE PlanUp website