Press release: Call for UN carbon credit mechanism to reject Guatemalan project following allegations of murder and intimidation
Guatemala City-Brussels – In a meeting starting today, the Executive Board of the UN’s Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) will decide whether to approve the Santa Rita Hydroelectric plant in Guatemala. The Peoples´Council of Tezulutlán and Carbon Market Watch call on the Board to reject this project because essential community consultation rules have been violated, tragically resulting in the alleged murders and intimidations of the affected community.
The Santa Rita Hydroelectric Plant (project 9713) is a project under development on the Icbolay River, in the municipality of Cobán, in the Alta Verapaz region of Guatemala and currently applying for approval under the UN’s carbon offsetting mechanism. The project is subject to community opposition over its environmental and social impacts and violation of community consultation rights which are at the heart of the Guatemalan Agreement on Identity and Rights of Indigenous Peoples.
A spokesperson for the Peoples´ Council of Tezulutlán who remains anonymous due to fear of reprisal at home stated: “We are calling on the CDM Board to reject the Santa Rita project and send a clear message that projects which bypass local indigenous communities rights, resulting in violence and intimidation are not tolerated by a United Nations mechanism.”
The CDM is an offsetting scheme that was established to help developed countries meet their climate commitments with cost effective emission reductions in developing countries. By generating carbon credits (1 credit = 1 tonne CO2 eq.) these projects are supposed to reduce overall global emissions while promoting sustainable development in host countries. This project is the first to be formally reviewed by the CDM Board on the grounds that the local stakeholder consultation was not carried out in the proper way.
Eva Filzmoser, Director of Carbon Market Watch said: “Sadly, we have seen many cases like this in the Clean Development Mechanism where local stakeholder rights have been ignored or forcibly silenced. This is the Board’s opportunity to draw a red line and start protecting human rights.”
At the upcoming UN climate negotiations in Peru in November later this year the CDM will be subject to a full reform. Last month Carbon Market Watch made detailed recommendations to improve rules on public participation in the mechanism and how grievances should be handled when projects harm local communities or the environment.
Notes to editors:
- UN official website: CDM Project 9713 : Santa Rita Hydroelectric Plant
- Note from the on how the consultations regarding the project have been carried out – Consejo de Pueblos de Tezulutlán Manuel Tot
- Campaign information on Santa Rita Hydroelectric Plant – Carbon Market Watch
- Views on suggested changes to the Modalities and Procedures (M&Ps) for the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) – Carbon Market Watch
Andrew Coiley, Communications and Outreach Officer
Tel: +32 (0)2 335 36 64
Maximo Ba´ Consejo de Pueblos de Tezulutlán
Tel +502 43 59 14 21
18 Dec 2020
Carbon Market Watch response to the Consultation of the Taskforce on Scaling Voluntary Carbon Markets
15 Dec 2020
Above and Beyond Carbon Offsetting – Alternatives to Compensation for Climate Action and Sustainable Development
Watch This! - Civil Society Newsletter
15 Dec 2020
Swiss/Peru offset link forged in Paris Agreement – Have we seen this all before?
3 Dec 2020