Digression: Clash of the Conventions (Newsletter #9)

The incredible profits made by HFC-23 projects are resulting in overproduction of cheap HCFC-22, and undermine global efforts under the Montreal Protocol to phase out HCFCs and move industry toward more environmentally friendly refrigerants.

The Montreal Protocol agreed in 2007 to accelerate the phase-out of HCFCs not just because of their ozone-destroying properties but also because they are potent greenhouse gases. In April 2010, the Montreal Protocol’s Multilateral Fund (MLF) agreed to guidelines on eligibility and criteria for funding the phase-out in developing countries.[1] As national phase-out plans are implemented, some developing countries will be in the position of receiving funding from the Montreal Protocol to reduce production of HCFC-22, while the CDM subsidises and promotes that same production.

The MLF has already identified that the facilities likely to be targeted for early phase-out are those registered under the CDM for HFC-23 destruction. The current CDM rules state that in order to be eligible for HFC-23 projects, HCFC-22 factories must have an operating history of at least three years between January 2000 and end of December 2004. As a result, older HCFC-22 factories tend to be those covered by the CDM, with newer ones not being eligible. This is likely to conflict with the accelerated HCFC phase-out, as older factories tend to be prioritised for closure.[2] Moreover, it is possible that CDM-financed older factories will displace newer factories with lower HFC-23/HCFC-22 ratios, and thus negate the potential to reduce the production of HFC-23 through technological improvements.[3]

There are also legitimate concerns that the CDM will exacerbate the potential for developing a black market trade in HCFC-22. The second largest HFC-23 facility under the CDM, Shandong Dongyue Chemical Company Ltd, which generates more than 10 million CERs each year, has previously been implicated in the illegal trade in ozone-depleting substances (ODS).[4]

Global HFC-23 emissions still rising[5]

The production of HCFC-22 is growing in developing countries by about 25% per year, and while the Montreal Protocol plans to phase out emissive (non-feedstock) uses by 2030, use for feedstock production is not controlled and is likely to continue to grow in developing countries.[6] As a result, global HFC-23 emissions have significantly increased over the last two decades, and although recent studies reveal a decline in emissions since 2006 associated with CDM destruction projects, over half of the developing world’s HFC-23 production is still emitted.

A 2009 study in Geophysical Research Letters examining atmospheric concentrations of HFC-23 estimated average global HFC-23 emissions for 2006-2008 at about 200 million tonnes CO2-eq per year, around 50% higher than levels derived for the 1990s.[7] The increase is attributed to developing country HCFC-22 production, with emissions in 2007 were estimated to be 160 million tonnes CO2-eq. The study noted that substantial amounts of HCFC-22 were produced but not covered by existing CDM projects (around 57% in 2007).[8]

[1] http://www.multilateralfund.org/news/1271429352850.htm

[2] Executive Committee of the Multilateral Fund for the Implementation of the Montreal Protocol. Further Elaboration and analysis of issues pertaining to the phase-out of HCFC production sector. UNEP/OzL.Pro/ExCom/57/61 27 February 2009

[3] Report of the 44th Meeting of the Methodologies Panel. 21-25 June 2010 http://cdm.unfccc.int/Panels/meth/index.html  The note on the revision request by the Methodoloy Panel can be found at http://cdm.unfccc.int/Panels/meth/meeting/10/044/mp44_an02.pdf

[4] EIA Briefing 2006. An Unwelcome Encore: The Illegal Trade in HCFCs, available from www.eia-international.org

[5] Chapter of the HFC-23 policy briefing paper by the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA) http://www.eia-international.org/ and CDM Watch

[6] Executive Committee of the Multilateral Fund for the Implementation of the Montreal Protocol. Further Elaboration and analysis of issues pertaining to the phase-out of HCFC production sector. UNEP/OzL.Pro/ExCom/57/61 27 February 2009.

[7] 1Gg HFC-23 = 1000 tonnes HFC-23 = 11,700,000 CO2-eq tonnes

[8] Montzka et al., ibid


Related posts

Lacklustre COP27 fails to bring clarity to carbon markets

The Sharm el-Sheikh climate conference’s final deal on Article 6 opens the door to secret carbon market deals between countries with little oversight. On a positive note, a new type of carbon credit could help spell the end of offsetting, but the agreement falls far short of what is needed.

Join our mailing list

Stay in touch and receive our monthly newsletter, campaign updates, event invites and more.